Buying Used Cars for Tax Season: Why Your Buy Center Should Start Now
If you want to be buying at full speed when refund checks land, your buy center has to start in November or December. Used retail sales historically peak in March or April as tax refunds reach consumers, according to Cox Automotive, and in March 2026 dealers had 37 days' supply of used vehicles, the lowest reading since 2021. A new private-seller buyer takes a few months to ramp, so the work that pays off in March starts now.
The short version
- Refunds were bigger in 2026: the IRS reported an average refund of $3,742 by February 27, up 10.6 percent from a year earlier.
- Affordable cars were scarce. Used cars under $15,000 had 27 days' supply in March 2026.
- A new buyer's first month lands at three to five cars. The 17-car monthly goal depends on a follow-up book that takes months to build.
When is tax refund season for used-car dealers?
For used-car dealers, tax refund season runs from February through April. Retail demand usually peaks in March or April, according to Cox Automotive. By the week ending February 27, 2026, the IRS had issued $136.6 billion in refunds, at an average of $3,742.
Cox Automotive linked spring 2026 demand to those refunds. Its first-quarter wholesale report said "higher-than-average tax refunds helped activate pent-up demand," and its March inventory report said demand was "likely supported by strong tax refunds."
Why is it hard to find used cars during tax season?
Used cars are hard to find during tax season because every dealer restocks for the same refund-driven demand at once. Cox counted 1.95 million used vehicles on dealer lots in March 2026, the lowest total in its data set going back to 2019. Days' supply fell to 37.
The squeeze reaches the affordable end of the lot. Used cars priced below $15,000 had only 27 days' supply in March, 10 days fewer than the market overall.
That sends more stores to auction just as wholesale values climb. Cox's Manheim index outlook said values "are expected to peak as tax refund season concludes." A store that waits until March to fill the gap is buying near that spring peak. What an auction car really costs lays out the fees on top of the hammer price.
How long does it take a new buyer to ramp?
A new private-seller buyer takes a few months to reach full pace. For a single dedicated buyer, the month-one goal Vehicle Acquisition Network (VAN) coaches set is three to five acquisitions, and across VAN launches the first month averages about four.
The 17 cars a month a ramped buyer works toward depend on a follow-up book: sellers who weren't ready the first time, cars still listed three weeks later, and owners who said no in month one and come back in month three. Buyers plan on about eight attempts before a seller answers. None of that exists on day one.
Work backward from March:
| Month | What the buy center is doing |
|---|---|
| November | Set the monthly goals for December through March, and name the person who owns them |
| December | The buyer reviews 100 listings a day and starts the follow-up book |
| January | Offers and appointments climb as the book fills in |
| February and March | The buyer is working toward the ramped goal as wholesale values typically climb in spring |
A buyer who starts in February is still ramping when refund checks land. The daily numbers behind each month are in buy center KPIs: the daily numbers that predict next month's cars.
What should a buy center do this month to prepare?
To prepare for tax season, a buy center should count its inventory gap, set monthly goals, name an owner, set rules for affordable cars and start the follow-up book.
- Count the gap. Take last year's February and March used retail and subtract what trades and lease returns gave you. That's the number every other source has to cover. The replenishment gap walks through the math.
- Set the goal by month. Set a goal for each month, December through March, so the plan already includes the ramp.
- Name the owner. Private-seller buying works when it is one person's whole job. Hire in-house, or bring in a VAN Managed Buyer™ who works your market from day one.
- Set the rules for cars under $15,000. They were scarce last spring. Set a maximum age and mileage and a recon cap, and confirm your lenders will finance them. If a private-seller car falls outside the rules, the buyer passes.
- Start the follow-up book now. Every seller your buyer talks to in December is a car that can still come in during March.
How does VAN help a buy center get ready for tax season?
VAN gets a buy center ready for tax season by giving its buyer private-seller cars to work now and a way to track the goal month by month. VAN is an acquisition CRM dealers use to buy used cars directly from private sellers. It brings private-seller listings from 25+ online marketplaces into one place, filters out dealer and scam listings, and gives the buyer the tools to reach sellers, track every conversation and set appointments.
VAN PACE™ holds the goal you set for each buyer and shows whether the month is on pace, so a slow December shows up in December. Stores that don't want to staff the seat can use a VAN Managed Buyer™, and most partners buy their first car within 30 days.
Frequently asked questions
When should a dealership start preparing for tax season?
Start in November or December. A new private-seller buyer's first month usually lands at three to five cars, and reaching the 17-car monthly goal depends on a follow-up book that takes months to build. A buyer who starts in February is still ramping when retail demand peaks in March or April.
Can a Managed Buyer be ready for tax season faster than a new hire?
A VAN Managed Buyer™ can start sooner, because there's no hire to make. It works your market from day one, and most partners buy their first car within 30 days. Getting to 17 cars a month still takes a few months of follow-up, so start before January.
How big was the average tax refund in 2026?
The IRS reported an average refund of $3,742 through the week ending February 27, 2026, up 10.6 percent from $3,382 a year earlier. By then it had issued $136.6 billion in refunds.
Is it better to buy at auction or from private sellers before tax season?
Most stores use both. Cox Automotive expected 2026 wholesale values to peak as tax refund season concluded, so a store that relies only on auction in March is buying near the spring peak. A private-seller pipeline built in December gives it a second source.
Next step
Book a demo or call 855-952-4949, and we'll show you the private-seller cars listed in your market today.
Sources: Cox Automotive, March 2026 used-vehicle inventory; Cox Automotive, Q1 2026 Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index; Cox Automotive, February 2024 used retail sales; IRS, 2026 filing season statistics.